Trending...
- AI Visibility: The Key to Beating Google's AI Overviews and Regaining Traffic
- New Mobile Car Detailing Platform Connects Drivers with On-Demand Local Pros
- Cal State LA secures funding for two artificial intelligence projects from CSU
BOSTON - Californer -- The impact of COVID-19 clearly has serious implications for humanity, and the measures needed to fight the pandemic present a profound challenge to policy makers. The choices are grim. Lockdowns slow the spread of the virus and reduce the pandemic's death toll, but they come at the cost of severe economic consequences. Proceeding with "business as usual" keeps the economy rolling, but forces us to endure human suffering and loss of life on a scale that many feel is totally unacceptable. In a time where data is in abundance—though possibly not always fully representative or to be trusted—many have focused on analyzing this data to infer the characteristics of the pandemic, creating models aimed at forecasting its development while arguing about how such data and forecasts should be used as inputs to decision making.
In this context, it is important to debate and to make sure that points of discussion (and disagreement) eventually bring constructive outcomes that help steer us in a fruitful direction. Nassim Taleb and John Ioannidis, two renowned thinkers and academics, have provided opposing views on how to deal with the pandemic. Over the last few months they have been highly visible in the media, conveying messages that to many have appeared to be in conflict. At the core of the argument lies the very question of forecasting for crisis management in the case of a pandemic, based on the quality and value of the forecasts produced.
More on The Californer
This question is of utmost importance with respect to how the current pandemic should be dealt with, as well as health crises that surely are lurking in the future. Whatever course we take will profoundly affect our societies and economies for years—and possibly decades—to come. We at the International Institute of Forecasting (IIF) and the International Journal of Forecasting (IJF) believe that a well-organized scientific debate between John Ioannidis and Nassim Taleb is the right approach to alert and inform relevant stakeholders, who can then better appraise their vision and recommendations about what needs to be done. We are fortunate that Taleb and Ioannidis have accepted our offer to debate, first by posting a blog post (link) and then writing a paper addressing each other's views, to be peer-reviewed and then published by the IJF. A number of coauthors joined them in that scientific debate.
After having carefully studied their blogs and initial papers, we can confirm that there is a lot to learn from their views, which are not always as far apart as they at first may seem. Unsurprisingly, each advocates using a rigorous scientific approach to inform decision making, based on an understanding of data and of the characteristics of the uncertainties involved. There are major differences, too. On the one hand, Nassim Taleb has clearly expressed that measures to stop the spread of the pandemic must be taken as soon as possible: instead of looking at data, it is the nature of a pandemic with a possibility of devastating human impact that should drive our decisions. On the other hand, John Ioannidis acknowledges the difficulty in having good data and of producing accurate forecasts, while believing that eventually any information that can be extracted from such data and forecasts should still be useful, e.g. to having targeted lockdowns (in space, time, and considering the varying risk for different segments of the population).
More on The Californer
One certainty is that COVID-19 caught humanity off guard, and forced many decision makers to act rapidly and take strong measures under very high levels of uncertainty. As the pandemic continues to spread, two important actions must now occur. First, as more reliable information is becoming available, we need to stop the blame game and join forces on how to proceed. Second, we must bring together what we have learned from the current pandemic to help future generations face new and potentially more severe ones that epidemiologists believe are waiting in the wings. We hope that this initiative with Nassim Taleb and John Ioannidis will contribute toward guiding us to positive outcomes. Other efforts are underway, e.g. a complete special issue of the IJF and an open scientific debate at the IIF's annual International Symposium on Forecasting.
In this context, it is important to debate and to make sure that points of discussion (and disagreement) eventually bring constructive outcomes that help steer us in a fruitful direction. Nassim Taleb and John Ioannidis, two renowned thinkers and academics, have provided opposing views on how to deal with the pandemic. Over the last few months they have been highly visible in the media, conveying messages that to many have appeared to be in conflict. At the core of the argument lies the very question of forecasting for crisis management in the case of a pandemic, based on the quality and value of the forecasts produced.
More on The Californer
- Rachel Farris, CPA Featured on The AJ Brown Show to Discuss Act 60 Tax Incentives
- Brindle Pet Supplies Now Carries Badlands Ranch Dog Food in Canada
- Jade & Zelda Launch Virtually Human: A Groundbreaking Podcast Hosted by AI-Powered Virtual Humans
- Dr. Satyam Priyadarshy Joins Indemnify AI to Enrich AI Risk Financial Quantification
- $10 Million Allocated to Establish Crypto Treasury Focused on High Value Ethereum (ETH) & Bitcoin (BTC) as Long-Term Holdings for Cybersecurity Leader
This question is of utmost importance with respect to how the current pandemic should be dealt with, as well as health crises that surely are lurking in the future. Whatever course we take will profoundly affect our societies and economies for years—and possibly decades—to come. We at the International Institute of Forecasting (IIF) and the International Journal of Forecasting (IJF) believe that a well-organized scientific debate between John Ioannidis and Nassim Taleb is the right approach to alert and inform relevant stakeholders, who can then better appraise their vision and recommendations about what needs to be done. We are fortunate that Taleb and Ioannidis have accepted our offer to debate, first by posting a blog post (link) and then writing a paper addressing each other's views, to be peer-reviewed and then published by the IJF. A number of coauthors joined them in that scientific debate.
After having carefully studied their blogs and initial papers, we can confirm that there is a lot to learn from their views, which are not always as far apart as they at first may seem. Unsurprisingly, each advocates using a rigorous scientific approach to inform decision making, based on an understanding of data and of the characteristics of the uncertainties involved. There are major differences, too. On the one hand, Nassim Taleb has clearly expressed that measures to stop the spread of the pandemic must be taken as soon as possible: instead of looking at data, it is the nature of a pandemic with a possibility of devastating human impact that should drive our decisions. On the other hand, John Ioannidis acknowledges the difficulty in having good data and of producing accurate forecasts, while believing that eventually any information that can be extracted from such data and forecasts should still be useful, e.g. to having targeted lockdowns (in space, time, and considering the varying risk for different segments of the population).
More on The Californer
- Fact: Trump lied — again. California gas prices remain lower than a week ago, month ago, and a year ago
- Sing For Your Supper: A Night of Musical Comedy and Drag for a Great Cause
- Top "We Buy Houses" Companies in Oakland, CA Announced — JiT Home Buyers Leads the Pack in 2025
- Ansira Appoints Amalia Thomas As Chief Revenue Officer
- Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies Celebrates New DBH Graduates
One certainty is that COVID-19 caught humanity off guard, and forced many decision makers to act rapidly and take strong measures under very high levels of uncertainty. As the pandemic continues to spread, two important actions must now occur. First, as more reliable information is becoming available, we need to stop the blame game and join forces on how to proceed. Second, we must bring together what we have learned from the current pandemic to help future generations face new and potentially more severe ones that epidemiologists believe are waiting in the wings. We hope that this initiative with Nassim Taleb and John Ioannidis will contribute toward guiding us to positive outcomes. Other efforts are underway, e.g. a complete special issue of the IJF and an open scientific debate at the IIF's annual International Symposium on Forecasting.
Source: International Institute of Forecasters, Inc.
0 Comments
Latest on The Californer
- VoiceGenie AI empowers small businesses with 24/7, brand-driven customer engagement through an AI-powered virtual front desk receptionist
- California: Governor Newsom signs tribal-state gaming compact 7.14.25
- VoiceGenie AI empowers small businesses with human-like call answering and customer engagement—bridging the gap between automation and live
- New 24/7 AI solution transforms customer engagement and efficiency for small businesses seeking live virtual receptionist services
- Next-generation virtual receptionist service leverages AI to ensure every customer call and text is answered, enhancing efficiency and engagem
- Next-Gen AI Receptionist Elevates Customer Communication, Boosts Efficiency for Small Businesses
- California: Governor Newsom signs legislation 7.14.25
- New AI-Powered Platform from Kell Web Solutions Delivers 24/7 Professional, Automated Call Handling and Appointment Scheduling
- Kell Web Solutions Launches Next-Gen VoiceGenie AI Call Answering Service for Businesses
- 24/7 Conversational AI Platform Raises the Standard for Small Business Customer Engagement
- Pyro Marketing Launches New Website to Accelerate Growth for Fitness Brands
- QuickLogic Announces the Passing of Board Director Christine Russell
- KCON LA 2025, 106.3 RAIN FM 'Take Over' Special Event
- IEI USA Launches SHIELD Rugged Stainless Steel Panel PCs for Hygiene-Critical Industries
- In historic first, California powered by two-thirds clean energy – becoming largest economy in the world to achieve milestone
- North Island Credit Union Foundation Provides $5,000 in Teacher Grants To Benefit Educators & Students
- The Citizens Commission on Human Rights Annual Purple Heart Day Event will be Hosted at the Historic Fort Harrison
- Blake Harris the Leading Authority in International Asset Protection Joins Tom Hegna on "Financial Freedom with Tom Hegna"
- Wise Business Plans Emerges as a Go-To Partner for Angel Investors, VCs, Family Offices and Private
- Psychedelics for Vets? CCHR Cites History of Exploitation and Failed Science