Trending...
- California: Crime is down in San Francisco, key law enforcement partnerships yield successful results
- Grammy award-winning Cuban-Canadian artist Alex Cuba releases his 11th studio album, "Indole"
- California: Governor Newsom signs SB 41 to lower the cost of prescription drugs
As genetic testing advances, results may predict not just health but personality and intelligence, raising ethical questions.
PASADENA, Calif. - Californer -- Genetic testing can provide information about individuals' health by looking for mutations in DNA. The results may empower people to seek treatment, adopt healthier habits, and better prepare them for the future.
A large portion (https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/gen...) of testing determines individuals' risk for having, developing, or being a carrier of a genetic disorder. Depending on the reasons for the test (https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/gen...), the results are used differently. A positive diagnostic test may mean starting a treatment plan. A carrier test may be useful before having children.
Another type of testing used in family planning is preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). This looks for markers of diseases and disorders in an embryo. PGD has been at the center of much controversy especially for those that believe life begins at fertilization. However, U.S. laws and health policy do not confirm this belief as they progressively place greater moral status on embryos, fetuses, and newborns as they develop.
More on The Californer
Opponents also object to this type of genetic testing believing it will lessen genetic diversity (https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/preimplantation-genetic-diagnosis/2001-08). Advocates for those with disabilities add selection discriminates against those with disabilities. Those against PGD argue parents will begin selecting based not just on "health" but preferences for things such as appearance, "talent, personality...even though it is not technically possible at this time."
Discrimination based on genetic testing was a real concern before the passing of the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) in 2008. The law focuses on protecting people in employment and health insurance. But one article in the Oxford Academic Journal of Law and the Biosciences (https://academic.oup.com/jlb/advance-article/doi/10.1093/jlb/lsz016/5651192) explores how more accurate and precise testing may lessen protections in both areas. Empathy has proven to be an essential skill (https://ultrahealthagency.com/fighting-covid-19...) in healthcare professions. Medical schools and hospitals could look at results before admitting students and residents. But, tests may also work against people predicting liabilities rather than assets. In high-risk situations such as driving a school bus or flying planes, employers "may have a legitimate interest (https://academic.oup.com/jlb/advance-article/do...) in genetic factors that would, hypothetically, significantly increase the chance of suffering an epileptic attack."
More on The Californer
Some may argue those with genetic conditions use healthcare services more and therefore should contribute more to the cost (https://academic.oup.com/jlb/advance-article/do...). This system would punish people for something outside their control based on possibly inaccurate results. Furthermore, despite certain, outdated arguments (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11...) against, healthcare is a basic human right. Putting barriers to care will not create a healthier society, it will only push those that cannot access care further from the help they need.
Currently, genetic information is protected. While there is room for error, testing provides useful information. Knowing family history can encourage preventative actions. Since some of these conditions are multifactorial, environmental improvements and lifestyle changes can have a positive effect.
A large portion (https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/gen...) of testing determines individuals' risk for having, developing, or being a carrier of a genetic disorder. Depending on the reasons for the test (https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/gen...), the results are used differently. A positive diagnostic test may mean starting a treatment plan. A carrier test may be useful before having children.
Another type of testing used in family planning is preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). This looks for markers of diseases and disorders in an embryo. PGD has been at the center of much controversy especially for those that believe life begins at fertilization. However, U.S. laws and health policy do not confirm this belief as they progressively place greater moral status on embryos, fetuses, and newborns as they develop.
More on The Californer
- California invests nearly $5 billion for local projects to improve roadways, new alternative transport options
- City of Long Beach to Celebrate Completion of Ramona Park Signature Playground
- Long Beach to Host Citywide College & Career Expo on October 21
- America Anesthesia Partners Unveils New User-Friendly Website
- Intelassist Launches AI Exploratory Research to Support Client Growth
Opponents also object to this type of genetic testing believing it will lessen genetic diversity (https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/preimplantation-genetic-diagnosis/2001-08). Advocates for those with disabilities add selection discriminates against those with disabilities. Those against PGD argue parents will begin selecting based not just on "health" but preferences for things such as appearance, "talent, personality...even though it is not technically possible at this time."
Discrimination based on genetic testing was a real concern before the passing of the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) in 2008. The law focuses on protecting people in employment and health insurance. But one article in the Oxford Academic Journal of Law and the Biosciences (https://academic.oup.com/jlb/advance-article/doi/10.1093/jlb/lsz016/5651192) explores how more accurate and precise testing may lessen protections in both areas. Empathy has proven to be an essential skill (https://ultrahealthagency.com/fighting-covid-19...) in healthcare professions. Medical schools and hospitals could look at results before admitting students and residents. But, tests may also work against people predicting liabilities rather than assets. In high-risk situations such as driving a school bus or flying planes, employers "may have a legitimate interest (https://academic.oup.com/jlb/advance-article/do...) in genetic factors that would, hypothetically, significantly increase the chance of suffering an epileptic attack."
More on The Californer
- HiClean Tools Debuts Compact 2100 PSI Electric Pressure Washer: Unleash Powerful Cleaning in a Portable Design
- MacCase Announces New 2025 13-inch iPad Pro M5 and 11-inch iPad Pro M5 Cases
- Bùng Nổ Ra Mắt, AALIVE Tung Gói Thưởng 68% và Dàn Game Thuần Việt Hấp Dẫn
- ARCH Dental + Aesthetics Offers Free Consultations for New Patients
- Maisano Brothers Inc. Expands National Paving Division Into Tampa, Florida
Some may argue those with genetic conditions use healthcare services more and therefore should contribute more to the cost (https://academic.oup.com/jlb/advance-article/do...). This system would punish people for something outside their control based on possibly inaccurate results. Furthermore, despite certain, outdated arguments (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11...) against, healthcare is a basic human right. Putting barriers to care will not create a healthier society, it will only push those that cannot access care further from the help they need.
Currently, genetic information is protected. While there is room for error, testing provides useful information. Knowing family history can encourage preventative actions. Since some of these conditions are multifactorial, environmental improvements and lifestyle changes can have a positive effect.
Source: ultraHealth Agency
Filed Under: Health
0 Comments
Latest on The Californer
- Thousands to Ride to L.A. Children's Hospital This Halloween Night
- Essential Living Support Opens First VA Medical Foster Home in Cheyenne, Wyoming
- Top AI Jobs for Recent College Grads
- City of Long Beach Reports First Human Case of West Nile Virus This Year
- Founder of Threshold Aviation selected as finalist for 2025 Spirit of the Entrepreneur Awards
- City of Long Beach Introduces Interest Form to Connect Local Businesses and Property Owners with 2028 Games Stakeholders
- Six-Figure Chicks Book Series 96 Authors, 6 Volumes Published to Empower and Mentor Women Nationwide
- MTN WTR Partners with Sumo + Sushi 2025 U.S. Tour to Celebrate Japanese Culture Across Five Cities
- Hundreds of new homes for veterans are coming to California through voter-approved Prop 1 funding
- LSC Destruction Launches Cutting-Edge Cryptocurrency Scanning to Hard Drive Destruction Services
- California highlights earthquake preparedness for Great ShakeOut Day
- DALPS Announces Global Airdrop to Reward Users and Expand Its Offers Marketplace
- Governor Newsom expands response arsenal with new emergency services facility in Southern California
- ALYXX Features on Oceans In Silhouette "Under My Skin" Single
- $150 Million Financing Initiates N A S D A Q's First Tether Gold Treasury Combining the Stability of Physical Gold with Blockchain $AURE
- DALPS Launches Marketplace Allowing Businesses to Trade Offers Like Stocks
- California: Governor Newsom announces affordable CalRx® insulin, $11 a pen, will soon be available for purchase
- Cardirun Foldable Treadmill for Home and Office, 10% Incline, 320 LBS Weight Capacity
- Podcast for Midlife Women Entrepreneurs Celebrates 100th Episode with Rhea Lana's Founder and CEO
- What If Help Could Come Before the Fall?